Erik ten Hag’s tenure at Manchester United has come to an abrupt end, marking a significant shift in the club’s management following a series of challenges both on and off the field.
Ten Hag, known for his meticulous approach and control over the smallest details, had been brought in with hopes of rejuvenating the Red Devils.
However, a mix of internal conflicts, declining results, and high-level scrutiny ultimately led to his departure. Here are the key reasons why Ten Hag’s reign was cut short:
1. Overwhelming Control and Micromanagement
Ten Hag’s desire for control extended far beyond the pitch, overseeing everything from locker layouts to field length. This approach left him responsible for nearly every detail of the club’s operations. While he intended to create a high-performing, well-oiled machine, this exhaustive control meant there was no excuse for failure — every misstep was his to own.
2. Dismal Start to the 2024-25 Season
Manchester United’s slow start to the 2024-25 season was a major factor in Ten Hag’s sacking. With just four wins in 13 matches and sitting 14th in the Premier League table, United faced the real possibility of surpassing last season’s poor record. A string of losses and their standing near the relegation zone proved decisive for the club’s leadership.
3. High-Level Restructuring and New Ownership Scrutiny
The recent acquisition of a 27.7% stake by Sir Jim Ratcliffe and his Ineos team added new pressure to the club’s management. Following a detailed review, Ratcliffe’s team sympathized with Ten Hag’s challenges but ultimately found his control style and performance issues problematic. The new ownership was initially patient but grew increasingly concerned about the recurring problems under Ten Hag’s leadership.
4. High-Profile Conflicts with Star Players
Ten Hag’s strict disciplinary style clashed with some of United’s biggest names, notably Cristiano Ronaldo and Jadon Sancho. While Ten Hag’s authority was respected by some, senior players began to question his handling of star talent, particularly after Ronaldo’s isolation from the squad for refusing a substitution. This disconnect between Ten Hag’s methods and his players’ preferences added tension to an already challenging season.
5. Inconsistent Communication Style
Many players found Ten Hag difficult to read, alternating between extremely strict and light-hearted moods. Some noted that his inconsistent communication style led to confusion on the pitch and frustration within the dressing room. This lack of clarity was problematic for a squad that had already been through managerial changes and needed a stable guiding force.
6. The Cristiano Ronaldo Fallout
The highly publicized fallout between Ten Hag and Ronaldo had long-lasting repercussions. Ten Hag’s decision to ban Ronaldo from the dressing room and require him to train separately after refusing to substitute in a game against Tottenham drew mixed reactions from the squad. The incident highlighted Ten Hag’s strict, uncompromising style, which alienated some senior players and raised questions about his flexibility in managing high-profile personalities.
7. The Unresolved Jadon Sancho Saga
Ten Hag’s relationship with Jadon Sancho also became strained, underscoring his difficulties in managing young talent. Sancho, once a coveted signing, faced issues both on and off the field, and the breakdown in communication with Ten Hag made it difficult for him to realize his potential. This unresolved tension highlighted deeper challenges within the squad and contributed to Ten Hag’s eventual dismissal.
8. Unconventional Game Preparation Methods
Ten Hag introduced new match-day routines, requiring players to drive themselves to Old Trafford four hours before games rather than staying together in a hotel the night before. While meant to enhance focus, this change proved divisive among players and disrupted a long-standing routine that had previously unified the squad before matches.
9. Mixed Results Despite Club’s Investment
Manchester United invested in Ten Hag’s vision, allowing him control over facilities, including revamping the video analysis room and restructuring pregame routines. However, while his tenure included a couple of trophy wins, his teams often underperformed in key matches. Early defeats to Brighton and Brentford in 2022 left players concerned, and Ten Hag’s unclear instructions contributed to a lack of direction on the field.
10. Coaching Staff Changes and Uncertain Support
Despite bringing in familiar faces like Rene Hake and new additions like Ruud van Nistelrooy, Ten Hag’s coaching revamp did not yield the results United hoped for. Players speculated that Van Nistelrooy, who ultimately replaced Ten Hag as caretaker manager, was being positioned as his successor. This shift in the coaching team — combined with management’s hesitation about Ten Hag’s future — contributed to a climate of uncertainty that culminated in his exit.
Don’t miss out! Get your daily dose of Entertainment news and more straight to your phone. Join Ghana Street Journal Whatsapp channel now!
